Hemp Extraction Methods for Business: CO2, Ethanol and Hydrocarbon Compared
Choosing an extraction method is first a decision about permits, safety engineering and regulatory risk, and only then a decision about chemistry. This guide is for founders, investors and farm operators who are considering an extraction business or a toll-processing partner. It compares supercritical CO2, ethanol and hydrocarbon (butane or propane) systems on the things that decide whether a facility opens and stays open: fire code, OSHA exposure, alcohol permits, residual-solvent limits, and the federal hemp definition that takes effect on December 11, 2026. It is not a how-to.
- The extraction market is large but volatile. USDA NASS valued 2025 floral hemp sold for extraction at $259 million, at an average of $35.80 per pound, compared with $64.80 in 2023.
- Under the fire code, extraction equipment generally has to be listed to UL 1389, or reviewed by a registered design professional, and approved by the fire code official before it is installed.
- Hydrocarbon systems face the strictest controls: continuous gas detection, emergency shutoff and exhaust that keeps vapors below 25% of the lower explosive limit.
- Ethanol users need the right type of alcohol. TTB says completely denatured alcohol needs no permit, while specially denatured alcohol requires a permit and records.
- Most of the new federal hemp definition, including the 0.3% total-THC limit on intermediate products such as crude and distillate, takes effect December 11, 2026, according to CRS.
Table of Contents
The market for extraction
USDA NASS defines extracting as a process that draws essential oils from raw floral hemp, and it reports floral hemp sold for extraction as its own category. The numbers show both scale and volatility:
| Year | Production for extraction (lb) | Harvested, not sold (lb) | Price per lb | Value of utilized production |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 3.11 million | 196,000 | $64.80 | $189.2 million |
| 2024 | 11.28 million | 430,000 | $22.80 | $247.4 million |
| 2025 | 9.49 million | 2.24 million | $35.80 | $259.1 million |
In 2025, almost a quarter of the floral hemp grown for extraction was harvested but not sold, the highest share in the three years shown. For an extractor, that means abundant biomass but a crowded field of buyers and processors. Our floral hemp economics guide covers the grower side.
The three methods at a glance
A 2022 peer-reviewed review in Molecules by Al Ubeed and colleagues compared extraction techniques for cannabis. It did not rank them with a single yield table, but it drew several business-relevant contrasts. Ethanol was reported to be efficient at extracting acidic cannabinoids, but it also pulls chlorophyll, which colors the product and affects taste. Conventional solvent extraction gave higher oil yield but lower CBD than supercritical CO2. The review called butane one of the cheapest and most efficient solvents but noted it is hard to handle in large batches because it is highly flammable, colorless and odorless. It also found closed-loop systems much safer than open-loop setups. On cost, the authors note that commercial-scale setup cost is a major limitation for the advanced techniques.
| Factor | Supercritical CO2 | Ethanol | Hydrocarbon (butane/propane) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main hazard | High pressure; CO2 displacing oxygen | Flammable liquid vapors | Flammable gas; explosion risk |
| Fire code focus | CO2 system rules (in some codes above 100 lb of CO2) | Flammable liquid storage, ventilation, electrical classification | Gas detection, emergency shutoff, exhaust, hazardous-location electrical |
| Solvent paperwork | Gas supply and cylinder safety | TTB rules depend on alcohol type | Gas supply; strict venting rules |
| Residual solvent concern | Low (CO2 is not a listed solvent) | Class 3 solvent; 5,000 ppm general ICH limit | California cannabis limit 5,000 µg/g for butane and propane |
| Product notes (Al Ubeed et al. 2022) | Higher CBD share than conventional solvent extraction in cited work | Efficient for acidic cannabinoids; extracts chlorophyll | Cheap and efficient; hard to handle at scale |
Fire code: the gate you must pass
Most U.S. jurisdictions regulate extraction through the fire code, either the International Fire Code (IFC) or NFPA 1. Your local fire marshal is often the decisive regulator.
IFC Chapter 39, Processing and Extraction Facilities
The 2021 edition of the IFC includes Chapter 39, which applies to facilities where plant processing and solvent-based extraction take place. Ohio, for example, adopted the 2021 IFC Chapter 39 by reference, with state modifications, in a rule effective November 20, 2025. The 2025 California Fire Code includes the same chapter. Key provisions in that published text:
- Equipment listing (3904.2.1): extraction equipment must be listed and labeled to UL 1389 and installed according to the listing.
- Unlisted equipment (3904.2.2): it must be reviewed by a registered design professional and approved for the specific use. A technical report goes to the fire code official for approval and is required before the equipment is placed or installed.
- Flammable-gas solvents (3905): a gas detection system, emergency shutoff for gaseous hydrocarbon systems, and exhaust that keeps flammable vapors from exceeding 25% of the lower explosive limit.
NFPA 1 Chapter 38
NFPA’s own committee records show that Chapter 38 was added to NFPA 1 for the 2018 edition to set safety rules for marijuana growing, processing and extraction facilities. Its solvent provisions are divided into liquefied petroleum gas, flammable and combustible liquids, and CO2. Draft language required equipment listed for the specific use or, failing that, a designer of record and peer review by a licensed professional engineer. Check the current edition your jurisdiction uses, and whether it applies the chapter to hemp. We could not confirm the current scope language.
Washington’s earlier state amendment shows how detailed local rules can get. It required continuous gas detection set no higher than 25% of the LEL for hydrocarbon solvents, prohibited releasing LP gas to the atmosphere, required emergency power for a safe shutdown plus two more hours, and applied specific rules to CO2 systems holding more than 100 pounds of CO2.
Business takeaway: budget for a code consultant or engineer and a pre-application meeting with the fire marshal before you sign a lease. A building that cannot meet ventilation, electrical classification or separation requirements can sink a hydrocarbon plan on its own.
OSHA and worker safety
Federal OSHA has no extraction-specific standard, but its general rules apply, and it is paying attention. In July 2024, OSHA’s Denver and Englewood area offices launched a Local Emphasis Program that explicitly targets marijuana and hemp processors. The directive names hazards including fire and explosion from flammable liquids and compressed gases, exposure to hexane, heptane, ethanol and butane, and oxygen displacement from CO2 systems. Those offices reported 44 complaint, fatality and referral inspections over seven years, including three fatalities. The most common citations involved hazard communication, respiratory protection, flammable liquid storage and handling, electrical hazards, falls and PPE.
| OSHA standard | What it requires (summary) | Most relevant to |
|---|---|---|
| 29 CFR 1910.106, Flammable liquids | Storage and handling rules; no more than 60 gallons of Category 1–3 liquids per storage cabinet | Ethanol |
| 29 CFR 1910.119, Process safety management | Applies to processes with 10,000 lb or more of a flammable gas or low-flashpoint liquid, with some exemptions | Large hydrocarbon or ethanol inventories |
| 29 CFR 1910.1200, Hazard communication | Written hazard communication program at each workplace | All methods |
| 29 CFR 1910.134, Respiratory protection | Respirators when needed to protect employee health, with a program | All methods |
| 29 CFR 1910.101, Compressed gases | Employer must confirm cylinders are in safe condition | CO2, hydrocarbon |
CO2 is often thought of as the “safe” option, but it is an asphyxiant at high concentrations. The NIOSH Pocket Guide lists an OSHA exposure limit of 5,000 ppm (8-hour average), a NIOSH short-term limit of 30,000 ppm, and an immediately dangerous level of 40,000 ppm. CO2 rooms need monitoring and ventilation too.
Solvent rules: TTB and residual limits
Ethanol and TTB
The Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau regulates nonbeverage alcohol. TTB says completely denatured alcohol (CDA) may be used without permit restrictions because its denaturants make it very hard to divert to drinking. Specially denatured alcohol (SDA) is different. TTB requires SDA users to keep records of receipt and use, file an annual report (Form 5150.18), and give suppliers a copy of their permit. Tax-free undenatured alcohol is limited by statute (26 U.S.C. 5214) to specified users such as educational institutions, research labs and hospitals. It cannot be used to make products for sale, so it is generally not an option for a commercial extractor. The denaturant you choose also affects what you can sell, so confirm with buyers and with TTB before you commit.
Residual solvent limits
Buyers will test for residual solvents, and state rules may set limits. Two reference points:
| Solvent | ICH Q3C(R9) guideline | California cannabis rule (4 CCR § 15718) |
|---|---|---|
| Ethanol | Class 3; 5,000 ppm general limit | 5,000 µg/g (not applied to tinctures) |
| Hexane | Class 2; 290 ppm | 290 µg/g |
| Heptane, pentane | Class 3; 5,000 ppm general limit | 5,000 µg/g |
| Butane, propane | Not listed | 5,000 µg/g |
The California rule applies to licensed cannabis, not necessarily to hemp, and ICH Q3C is a pharmaceutical guideline. Your state hemp or food program may set its own limits. See how to read a certificate of analysis and THC testing and compliance.
Federal law and FDA in 2026
The Congressional Research Service’s Legal Sidebar LSB11496 (October 28, 2026) sets out the current timeline. P.L. 119-37 (November 2025) redefined hemp on a total-THC basis. A September 2026 continuing resolution, P.L. 119-103, delayed most of the changes to December 11, 2026. The exclusion of cannabinoids the plant cannot naturally produce took effect as planned on November 12, 2026. Several provisions directly affect extractors once they apply:
- Intermediate products, such as crude and distillate, that contain more than 0.3% total THC and similar cannabinoids are excluded from hemp.
- Final products with more than 0.4 mg combined total THC and similar cannabinoids per container are excluded.
- Cannabinoids synthesized or manufactured outside the plant are excluded, which affects conversion products.
CRS also notes that, as of its publication, FDA had not issued the lists of cannabinoids or the guidance on “container” that the law required. CRS lists bills that would delay the changes two more years (H.R. 7024, H.R. 7010, S. 3686) or repeal them (H.R. 6209). These are pending, not law. We checked this status on November 18, 2026. See the new federal hemp definition explained and what the changes mean for processors.
FDA’s position on CBD has not changed. FDA has concluded that THC and CBD products are excluded from the dietary supplement definition, and that adding them to food in interstate commerce is a prohibited act. Make no health claims; see our CBD marketing claims guide.
Rules change; confirm with your state department of agriculture and USDA AMS before acting.
Cost and business model
We did not find a credible, current peer-reviewed or university techno-economic comparison of CO2, ethanol and hydrocarbon extraction, so we do not publish equipment or per-pound processing costs. The cost drivers are clear from the rules above:
- Building and code compliance: hydrocarbon rooms need gas detection, emergency shutoff, exhaust and hazardous-location electrical. Ethanol needs flammable-liquid storage and ventilation. CO2 needs pressure safety and oxygen monitoring.
- Engineering review: unlisted or modified equipment triggers a technical report before installation.
- Throughput and post-processing: winterization, solvent recovery, distillation and remediation steps add equipment and labor beyond the extractor itself.
- Testing and compliance: residual solvents, potency and total THC on every lot, and quality systems if you sell into regulated channels.
- Regulatory exposure: under the new definition, inventory of crude or distillate above 0.3% total THC is a legal risk, not just a quality issue.
Common models include toll processing (extracting farmers’ biomass for a fee), buying biomass and selling bulk ingredients, and vertically integrated brands. Each carries different working capital and price risk. This article is for education only and is not investment, legal, or tax advice.
Frequently asked questions
Which hemp extraction method is safest?
None is safe without engineering controls. Hydrocarbon systems carry the highest fire and explosion risk and the strictest code requirements. Ethanol is a flammable liquid. CO2 involves high pressure and can displace oxygen, with an OSHA exposure limit of 5,000 ppm.
Do I need a permit to use ethanol for extraction?
It depends on the alcohol. TTB says completely denatured alcohol can be used without a permit, while specially denatured alcohol requires a permit and record-keeping. Local fire code permits for flammable liquids are separate.
Does my extraction equipment have to be listed?
Under IFC Chapter 39 as adopted in states such as Ohio and California, equipment should be listed to UL 1389. Otherwise a registered design professional must review it and the fire code official must approve a technical report before installation.
How does the new hemp definition affect extractors?
From December 11, 2026, intermediate products above 0.3% total THC, final products above 0.4 mg total THC per container, and synthesized cannabinoids are excluded from hemp, according to CRS. Plan your inventory and remediation accordingly.
Can I sell CBD extract as a dietary supplement?
FDA’s position is that CBD products are excluded from the dietary supplement definition and cannot be added to food in interstate commerce.
Sources
- USDA NASS, National Hemp Report (April 16, 2026)
- Al Ubeed et al., A Comprehensive Review on the Techniques for Extraction of Bioactive Compounds from Medicinal Cannabis, Molecules (2022)
- 2025 California Fire Code, Chapter 39, Section 3904 Systems and Equipment (2025)
- 2025 California Fire Code, Chapter 39, Section 3905 Safety Systems (2025)
- Ohio Administrative Code 1301:7-7-39, Plant Processing (2025)
- NFPA, NFPA 1 Second Draft committee report (2016)
- Washington State Building Code Council, WAC 51-54A Chapter 38 amendment (2015)
- OSHA, CPL 24-04: Local Emphasis Program for the Cannabis Industry, Denver Region (2024)
- OSHA, 29 CFR 1910.106 Flammable Liquids
- OSHA, 29 CFR 1910.119 Process Safety Management
- NIOSH, Pocket Guide to Chemical Hazards: Carbon Dioxide
- TTB, Denatured Alcohol
- TTB, Maintaining Compliance as a Nonbeverage Alcohol Dealer or User
- 26 U.S.C. 5214, Withdrawal of distilled spirits free of tax (Cornell LII)
- ICH Q3C(R9) Guideline for Residual Solvents, EMA (2024)
- California Code of Regulations, 4 CCR § 15718 Residual Solvents (Cornell LII)
- Congressional Research Service, LSB11496: Delay in Changes to Hemp Definition (October 28, 2026)
- FDA, Regulation of Cannabis and Cannabis-Derived Products, Including CBD (2024)
Figures last checked: November 18, 2026.
Originally posted 2021-07-24 18:30:44. Republished by Blog Post Promoter
🌱 Finished reading? You earned 5 seeds.
Every article you read to the end earns seeds in Hemp Empire, our free hemp farming tycoon game. Play now →
Some links may be affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, HempDollars earns from qualifying purchases.

